CAPE MAY, NJ - While in Cape May, you should make it a point to dine at one of the many fine dining restaurants. Some of our top picks are: Lucky Bones Back Water Grille (also known as Back Water Grille), The Blue Pig Tavern (also known as The Blue Pig Tavern), Tisha's Fine Dining, and The Mad Batter Restaurant and Bar. Continue reading to learn more about each restaurant.


The Top 25 Restaurants in Cape May

1. Lucky Bones Back Water Grille

The casual but upscale Lucky Bones Backwater Grille on the waterfront blends three distinct environments: an open-air brick oven pizzeria overlooking the bay, a bright, romantic dining room, and a rectangle bar. It is a casual restaurant, but it attracts a lot of people. The restaurant offers a Happy Hour, and you can stay until late. Enjoy a drink with your meal at the bar. 1200 NJ-109, Cape May, NJ 08204

2. The Blue Pig Tavern

The Blue Pig Tavern is part of the famous Congress Hall Hotel in Cape May. The Blue Pig Tavern is known for serving classic American food and seasonal ingredients. The menu features local produce, fresh seafood, and a grilled Berkshire pork from Beach Plum Farm. It's worth looking through the menu to see if you can find something that you like. 20 Congress Pl, Cape May, NJ 08204

3. Tisha’s Fine Dining

Tisha's fine dining is located in Cape May's historic district. This cozy restaurant offers New American cuisine, such as sandwiches and hamburgers. The charming ambiance offers a great view of the waterfront. The charming dining room is open for lunch. Try the daily specials or takeout specials for a quick snack. The menu offers daily specials, as well as a weekend brunch, during the week. Cape May, NJ, 08204

4. Peter Shields Inn

The Peter Shields Inn has become one of Cape May’s most popular spots in the historic Peter Shields Mansion. This charming eatery offers American cuisine in an upscale environment with a laid-back and fun vibe. The restaurant is located in a mansion from 1907 and offers a lively and friendly atmosphere. The Peter Shields Inn is known for its burgers and small plates. It also serves American food in a cozy atmosphere. 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

5. Alethea's restaurant

This upscale Cape May, New Jersey restaurant offers a waterfront dining experience. The Victorian Inn offers upscale American food. The Victorian Inn offers a variety of dining options, including a sophisticated meal or upscale cocktails at the bar. Aleathea’s Restaurant offers a fantastic harbor view along the Cape May waterfront. Book a table at this restaurant to understand Cape May's past and present. 8 Ocean St, Cape May, NJ 08204

6. 410 Bank Street Restaurant

410 Bank St. has been in business for 15 years and continues thriving under new management. The restaurant takes pride in its service, a problem at many Cape May restaurants. 410 Bank St. has continued to improve service despite staff shortages. Continue reading to learn about some of the key improvements made by this restaurant. This restaurant has received rave reviews for 15 years from both locals and tourists. 410 Bank St. Cape May, NJ 8204

7. Black Duck on Sunset

Black Duck on Sunset in Cape May, New Jersey, serves a variety of breakfast and lunch options. Many customers compliment the food's moderate price and praise its quality. The restaurant hosts private parties, rehearsal dinners, and catered events. The restaurant's Google rating of 4.6 indicates high customer satisfaction and friendly staff.

8. Louisa's Cafe

Louisa's Cafe, in Cape May, New Jersey, for many years, was the first to adopt the farm-to-table philosophy in America. The yellow building houses a charming dining area where local and regional food is prepared using fresh, high-quality ingredients. The restaurant serves fresh fish and produces along with dishes that have been expertly prepared. The owners of the cafe were Cape May residents for many years. They enjoyed dining there. Cape May, NJ, 08204

9. Viggiano’s on Sunset

Viggiano's is an authentic Italian restaurant. This restaurant on Sunset Boulevard across from Exit Zero Filling Station offers pizza and pasta. The Italian restaurant in Cape May, New Jersey, opened in the summer of 2019. New Jersey Monthly recently named it one of the 30 best new restaurants in the state. Mark Viggiano owns this restaurant, a son of Italians from the first generation. West Cape May, NJ, 08204

10. The Mad Batter Restaurant and Bar

Mad Batter Restaurant and Bar is an American-style restaurant that serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. A fun atmosphere is created by live music and an open bar. Listen to live music while you dance! The staff is friendly and relaxed. The staff encourages guests to bring their family and friends. Weekend jazz nights are a great way to enjoy live music and a night out. 19, Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204

11. The Pier House

Pier House offers a relaxed, beach-chic atmosphere perfect for enjoying a meal and admiring the breathtaking ocean views. The restaurant's casual atmosphere is enhanced by the white-and-white tiles on the floors and the accents in blue. The talented chefs prepare mouthwatering dishes using local and seasonal ingredients. Open daily for breakfast and lunch; the restaurant will satisfy your palate. Cape May, NJ, 08204

12. Washington Inn & Wine Bar

The Washington Inn is known for its fine dining. It has six dining areas, including an outdoor patio and a cozy fireplace nook. There are also indoor and outdoor dining options. Dine outside in the summer or enjoy a cocktail at one of the four restaurants. There are plenty of options for dining, whether you choose to dine al fresco in the summer on the patio or by the fireplace. Since 1840, the Washington Inn has stood out as a unique establishment. Mimi Wood has been its executive chef for nearly a decade. 801 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

13. George's Place

If you're in Cape May, NJ, craving Greek food, then George's Place is the place to go. The fresh Greek food served at this small corner restaurant makes it a popular choice. There are many menu choices to choose from. The restaurant is a diner during the day but transforms into a Greek tavern at night. "Opa!" "Opa!" is the Greek greeting. Enjoy a tasty meal and watch the sunset over the Atlantic Ocean while you enjoy the Greek tradition. 801 Washington St, Cape May NJ08204

14. Hemingway’s Steaks & Seafood

Hemingway’s Steaks and Seafood is one of Cape May’s most popular casual restaurants. The restaurant is known for its contemporary American cuisine featuring local seafood and steaks. The restaurant offers a unique "Sunset Dining Menu" that allows guests to enjoy the ocean view and a specialty cocktail while they dine. The Grand Hotel restaurant has a cozy atmosphere with TVs showing sports. 1045 Beach Ave., Cape May, NJ

15. Sapore Italiano

Sapore Italiano is in a Victorian mansion in West Cape May, New Jersey. It serves Italian cuisine. Chef Rimi uses local ingredients to create his menu. Many pasta dishes are also gluten-free. Many of the classic Italian dishes on the menu, such as spaghetti and gnocchi Pomodoro, are gluten-free. This is the perfect place to enjoy a meal with your family and host a dinner. 416 S Broadway, West Cape May, NJ 08204

16. The Lobster House

The Lobster House can be found on Fisherman's Wharf, Cape May, NJ. This restaurant, located in an old fishing village, is popular with locals and tourists. This restaurant is popular with seafood lovers. It is open year-round. The restaurant serves lunch and dinner. You can order cocktails and takeout to enjoy on the deck of the Schooner America. 906 Schellengers Landing Rd Cape May, NJ 8204

17. Vintage BYOB

Vintage BYOB is a great place to go for a unique dining experience. This casual dining place is located on the Emlen-Physick estate and offers a unique menu for all kinds of people. The restaurant's cuisine can be described in one word: "wild." The menu is relaxed and offers creative dishes with a twist. The patio and outdoor seating areas are available. Cape May, NJ, 08204

18. Iccara Italian Bistro

This cozy Sicilian restaurant offers seafood, steaks, and kids' food. Early bird specials are also popular. Iccara offers a BYOB option for those who want to spend an evening with friends. Bring your favorite wine with you. Cape May, NJ, 08204

19. Shamone BYOB at Cape May NJ

Shamone BYOB is the perfect place to dine with friends in Cape May, NJ. This upscale restaurant offers a multicourse tapas meal in a busy mall. The food is excellent, and the staff are friendly and helpful. Bring your own non-alcoholic beer, wine or other drinks. There is no corkage charge for guests who bring in their wine. This is an excellent option for groups or families. Cape May, NJ, 08204

20. Tisha's Fine Dining Cape May NJ

Tisha's Fine Dining, a small sit-down restaurant in CapeMay, NJ, serves modern New American cuisine. The patio is open to guests who bring their own wine or beer. Lunch is served at the restaurant, which offers sandwiches and hamburgers. You can enjoy a delicious meal with your friends or family or big group. Bring your wine or beer to Tisha’s. Cape May, NJ 08204

21. Cape May Fish Market

Comfortable joint with a raw bar, surf'n'turf entrees, and sandwiches & hamburgers. Outside tables are also available. A Cape May seafood restaurant must-try! Cape May is not complete without a visit to this charming establishment. Cape May's Fish Market offers a wide variety of fresh and well-seasoned Seafood. 408 Washington St, Cape May NJ 08204

22. Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls is a great place to go if you like seafood. The famous seafood restaurant chain has six locations, including Wildwood Sea Isle City, Ocean City, and Long Beach Island. Try the classic lobster roll or the Chicken Strips. Cape May, NJ will be memorable for you and your family. The menu includes lobster rolls in the style of Maine or Connecticut, served with condiments. The most popular appetizer is the lobster roll, which comes with butter and mayo. An outdoor area offers a beautiful view of Cape May Beach. 709 Beach Ave., Cape May, NJ, 08204

23. Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar

The restaurant is famous for its pub & grill, fresh seafood, and steak. The restaurant has a bar, a great spot to sample local beers and wines. The restaurant is on Lafayette Street opposite the Acme. The restaurant is off the beaten track, so it's a mix between locals and tourists. Don't forget about ordering some desserts while you're at the restaurant. There is a wide selection of desserts available to complete your meal. You'll be happy you did! 615 Lafayette St., Cape May, NJ 08204

24. H&H Seafood Market

You've found the best place to find a seafood market near Cape May, NJ. H&H Seafood Market offers delicious, fresh seafood at a reasonable price. The restaurant offers an extensive menu, making it an excellent place to take the family for dinner. You can also order carryout, so you don't need to dress up for dinner. The menu has plenty of options, including buckets of fresh crab and lobster. 956, Ocean Dr, Cape May (NJ) 08204

25. Brine BYOB

Brine is a waterfront restaurant located in Cape May, New Jersey. The Saltwater Cafe is located on the South Jersey Marina waterfront and serves American classic breakfast and lunch items and innovative and creative menu options. The restaurant accepts credit card payments and offers delivery. Customers can order food while on their way to a beach. 1231 NJ-109, Cape May, NJ 08204

Follow Us

 

Like what you see?

Hit the buttons below to follow us, you won't regret it...